What does NYDFS require for penetration testing?
New York asks for annual testing by a qualified party. Under 23 NYCRR 500.5, a covered entity must have penetration testing of its information systems at least once a year, from both inside and outside the systems' boundaries, performed by a qualified internal or external party. The rule took its current form in the Second Amendment, effective November 1, 2023.
Alongside the annual test, 500.5 asks for automated scans of information systems plus manual review, at a frequency set by your risk assessment and after any material change. New York does not set a fixed six-month scan cadence. It ties the frequency to your own documented risk assessment.
The rule wants a qualified party and a real test, not a specific brand or badge. Grapefruit delivers that test at a fixed price, with the report in about 10 days, and keeps re-testing on a plan.
What does inside and outside testing mean?
It means attacking from two vantage points. Outside testing takes the position of an attacker on the internet with no account, probing your public surface. Inside testing takes the position of someone who already has a foothold, such as a low-privilege user or a compromised account, and sees how far they can reach.
The two views catch different failures. An outside test finds the exposed login or API that should not be reachable. An inside test finds the user who can read another customer's file or reach an admin function. Grapefruit runs authenticated testing with real exploitation, using test accounts you supply, so both the outside and the inside paths are covered in one test.
How does NYDFS handle vulnerability scans?
New York ties scan frequency to your risk assessment, not to a fixed calendar. Under 500.5, covered entities run automated scans of their systems, plus manual review of systems not covered by those scans, at a frequency the risk assessment sets, and after any material change to systems or business operations.
This is a key difference from the federal rule. The FTC names a six-month scan cadence. New York leaves the cadence to your documented risk assessment, which for most firms with customer data points to frequent, recurring testing rather than a once-a-year check. A weekly or monthly re-test satisfies that expectation and dates each run for your file.
Who is a covered entity under Part 500?
Anyone operating under a New York financial license. Under 23 NYCRR 500.1, a covered entity is any person operating under or required to operate under a license, registration, charter or similar authorization under New York's Banking Law, Insurance Law or Financial Services Law. That pulls in a wide set of ordinary financial businesses.
If any of these describe you, Part 500 and its 500.5 testing requirement likely apply unless you qualify for a limited exemption.
- Mortgage brokers and mortgage bankers.
- Licensed lenders and other licensed non-bank lenders.
- Insurance agencies, brokers and producers.
- Money transmitters and check cashers licensed in New York.
- Other firms operating under a New York Banking, Insurance or Financial Services license.
Who qualifies for the 500.19 limited exemption?
Small entities get a limited exemption from the testing requirement. Under 23 NYCRR 500.19(a), a covered entity is exempt from 500.5 if it meets any one of three thresholds. Meeting a single threshold is enough. The exemption is limited, so other parts of Part 500 can still apply even when the testing requirement does not.
The thresholds look at headcount, New York revenue and total assets, shown below. Note that revenue is measured in each of the last three fiscal years, so a single strong year does not by itself remove the exemption.
| Threshold (meet any one) | The test |
|---|---|
| Headcount | Fewer than 20 employees and independent contractors |
| New York revenue | Under 7.5 million dollars in gross annual revenue from New York operations in each of the last three fiscal years |
| Total assets | Under 15 million dollars in year-end total assets |
How is NYDFS different from the FTC Safeguards Rule?
The two rules overlap but differ in the details. New York requires annual testing from both inside and outside your network, performed by a qualified party, and ties scan frequency to your risk assessment. The FTC Safeguards Rule offers an either-or between continuous monitoring and periodic testing, and names a six-month scan cadence on the periodic path.
The headcount and asset exemptions differ too. New York's 500.19 thresholds look at employees, New York revenue and total assets, while the FTC's 314.6 exemption looks at whether you maintain information on fewer than 5,000 consumers. A New York licensed firm can be covered by both rules at once, so a test built to satisfy 500.5 should also be scoped to meet the FTC requirement where it applies.
How does Grapefruit satisfy 500.5?
Grapefruit maps onto both parts of 500.5. The annual inside-and-outside test is one Grapefruit full test a year, run with test accounts you supply so both the external and the authenticated internal paths are covered. The recurring scanning half is a Grapefruit maintenance plan that re-tests your verified domains every week or month, dated for your risk-assessment file. One full test a year plus a Grapefruit maintenance plan covers both halves of the rule.
Every finding arrives with the request and response that proves it, ranked by severity in your portal. You replay it, fix it, and replay it to confirm the fix. The dated trail of findings and fixes is the record a DFS examiner expects.
- Annual half: one full penetration test from inside and outside, at a fixed quote, report in about 10 days.
- Recurring half: a maintenance plan re-testing weekly or monthly, each run dated for your risk assessment.
- Qualified testing with real exploitation against your web app, APIs and AI features in one test.
- Every finding carries captured request and response evidence you can replay.
- A dated portal trail of new and fixed findings, ready for a DFS examiner.
How do you start NYDFS testing with Grapefruit?
Add your hostname, publish one DNS TXT record and sign the testing authorization online. It takes a few minutes. Testing starts right after and the report lands in about 10 days at a fixed price. Because the law requires authorization, and testing without it is a crime under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030, the signed authorization and defined scope come first.
Pick a full penetration test for the annual inside-and-outside requirement, and a maintenance plan for the recurring scans your risk assessment calls for. Maintenance prices are public and checkout is by card. Run the compliance check to confirm your status, or see pricing to compare. This is a summary of public rules, not legal advice.
Questions
- Does NYDFS require annual penetration testing?
- Yes. Under 23 NYCRR 500.5, a covered entity must have penetration testing at least once a year, from both inside and outside its systems' boundaries, by a qualified internal or external party. The rule took its current form in the Second Amendment effective November 1, 2023. Alongside the test it asks for recurring scans at a risk-based frequency.
- Does New York require six-month vulnerability scans like the FTC?
- No. The six-month scan cadence is an FTC Safeguards Rule detail. New York ties scan frequency to your own risk assessment and to material changes under 500.5, rather than naming a fixed interval. For most firms with customer data, that points to frequent recurring testing, which a weekly or monthly plan satisfies and dates for your file.
- Am I a covered entity under Part 500?
- If you operate under a New York Banking Law, Insurance Law or Financial Services Law license, registration or charter, then under 23 NYCRR 500.1 you are a covered entity. That includes mortgage brokers and bankers, licensed lenders, and insurance agencies and producers. Check whether you meet a 500.19 exemption before assuming the testing requirement applies.
- How do the 500.19 small-entity exemptions work?
- Under 23 NYCRR 500.19(a) you are exempt from the testing requirement if you meet any one of three thresholds: fewer than 20 employees and contractors, under 7.5 million dollars in gross New York revenue in each of the last three years, or under 15 million dollars in year-end total assets. It is a limited exemption, so other Part 500 duties can still apply.
- What does inside and outside testing cover?
- Outside testing attacks your public surface as an internet attacker with no account. Inside testing starts from a foothold, such as a low-privilege user, and sees how far it reaches. The two catch different failures. Grapefruit runs authenticated testing with test accounts you supply, so both the external and internal paths are covered in one test.
- Can one test satisfy both NYDFS and the FTC rule?
- Often, yes. A New York licensed firm can be covered by both 23 NYCRR 500.5 and the FTC Safeguards Rule. A full test scoped to cover inside and outside testing meets 500.5, and a maintenance plan covers both the New York risk-based scans and the FTC six-month cadence. Run the compliance check to confirm which rules apply to you.